Home Page Button





This page is designed to aid you in assessing the validity of information you will find on the World Wide Web through the use of the Web Validity Wizard (VWiz). The VWiz will walk you through a variety of steps. You will be asked a series of questions, all of which you must respond to, even if the answer is "I don't know." There are a wide variety of questions, and sometimes the answers will require some effort. You might want to print out a copy of the questionnaire to consider before actually proceeding.

The VWiz will result in three estimate coefficients, each of which will be a value somewhere between zero and one. The three estimates measure internal validity, external validity, and overall validity. If either of your internal or external validity coefficients is low, then your overall validity will be low, and there is a good chance the source is not very valid. If both of your internal and external validity coefficients are high, then your overall validity will be high, and chances are that the Web source is a good one.



Please Respond to Each Item.

Please be sure to respond to each item below. If you are unsure of the answer, or if you believe the question is not applicable, then please check "DK/NA" (Don't Know or Not Applicable).

If your browser is JavaScript enabled, you can get help and additional guidance for any item by clicking on the question mark to the left of the item.

The assessment is conducted by asking you a series of questions arranged under three main categories. The categories inquire as to the nature of the Web Site, the Author, and the Content of the document.

Please enter the URL for the source:   





About the Web Site:

Does the domain
belong to an academic institution?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Does the domain belong
to a reputable entity or corporation?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Is the page located in a departmental or
root directory as opposed to an individual's?
Yes   No     DK/NA




About the Author:

Is the author's name
included on the Web page?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Does the author have credentials
that you have confirmed?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Has the author published scholarly
articles in academic print journals?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Has the author published articles
in the popular print press?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Does the author hold a position or have
interests that might bias his or her writing?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Is there a mechanism (e.g., email)
for contacting the author?
Yes   No     DK/NA



About the Document:
(Objective Items)


Does the document
contain a last revised date?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Is the last
revised
date recent?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Is the document
written in the third person?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Does the document cite other
sources in the form of URLs?
Yes   No     DK/NA

Does the document
cite in-print sources?
Yes   No     DK/NA



(Subjective Items)

Does the document
appear to be one-sided?


Does the document appear
to be informative or persuasive?


Does there appear to have been an
agenda behind the creation of the document?


Does the document elicit
credibility by being well written?


Does the document
utilize sound evidence?


Does the document
utilize sound reasoning?






Copyright © 1996, 2009 - EB Communications